The best suburbs of NYC for most people leaving the city are Hoboken, Montclair, Maplewood and Summit in New Jersey; Scarsdale, Bronxville, Rye and New Rochelle in Westchester; Garden City and Port Washington on Long Island; and Greenwich and Stamford in Connecticut. All 12 have rail service into Manhattan, but cost and commute vary widely.
This guide compares those towns using the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey for 2020 to 2024 and the official MTA, NJ Transit and PATH service maps. It also covers what changes when your move crosses a state line, from the paperwork your mover must carry to storage when a closing date slips.
The 12 best suburbs of NYC at a glance
Only three of the 12 suburbs have a median home value below New York City’s $777,600: Maplewood, New Rochelle and Stamford. All 12 have a higher median gross rent than the city’s $1,821, and 10 of the 12 have a shorter average commute than the city’s 40.3 minutes.
| Suburb | Train to Manhattan | Median home value | Median gross rent | Owner-occupied homes | Average commute (minutes) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hoboken, NJ | PATH to 33rd Street and World Trade Center | $895,100 | $2,938 | 33.8% | 36.8 |
| Montclair, NJ | NJ Transit Montclair-Boonton Line | $906,400 | $2,063 | 56.9% | 35.6 |
| Maplewood, NJ | NJ Transit Morris & Essex Lines | $720,700 | $2,269 | 74.9% | 38.5 |
| Summit, NJ | NJ Transit Morris & Essex Lines | $994,500 | $2,430 | 68.3% | 33.5 |
| Scarsdale, NY | Metro-North Harlem Line | $1,800,700 | $3,500+ | 92.3% | 42.5 |
| Bronxville, NY | Metro-North Harlem Line | $1,095,100 | $3,500+ | 84.2% | 41.3 |
| Rye, NY | Metro-North New Haven Line | $1,819,900 | $3,500+ | 70.4% | 39.8 |
| New Rochelle, NY | Metro-North New Haven Line | $702,500 | $1,917 | 53.7% | 32.5 |
| Garden City, NY | LIRR Hempstead Branch | $1,075,900 | $3,265 | 93.7% | 34.9 |
| Port Washington, NY | LIRR Port Washington Branch | $1,003,200 | $2,184 | 76.9% | 35.4 |
| Greenwich, CT | Metro-North New Haven Line | $1,695,700 | $2,674 | 70.0% | 29.6 |
| Stamford, CT | Metro-North New Haven Line | $624,400 | $2,276 | 48.8% | 28.5 |
| New York City | Subway | $777,600 | $1,821 | 32.8% | 40.3 |
Source: U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts, American Community Survey 5-year estimates, 2020 to 2024, for the New Jersey towns, the New York towns and Connecticut and New York City. Census shows medians above $3,500 a month as $3,500+. Train lines from the MTA railroad line maps, NJ Transit and PATH.
Two columns in that table deserve a second look before you build a shortlist.
- Owner-occupied homes tell you what you will find on the market. In Hoboken, 33.8% of occupied homes are owner-occupied, close to New York City’s 32.8%, so it is mostly a renter’s town. In Garden City (93.7%) and Scarsdale (92.3%) nearly every household owns, so rentals are scarce.
- Average commute is not a train schedule. Census averages the trip to work for every working resident aged 16 and older, including people who work in town. A low number, like Stamford’s 28.5 minutes, can mean many residents work locally rather than that the ride to Manhattan is fast. Check the timetable from your station to your office.
New Jersey suburbs: Hoboken, Montclair, Maplewood and Summit
New Jersey gives you the widest choice of housing within reach of Midtown. Hoboken suits renters who want PATH trains, while Montclair, Maplewood and Summit suit buyers who want a house on an NJ Transit line with Midtown Direct trains into Penn Station.
Hoboken
Hoboken has PATH service to 33rd Street and to the World Trade Center. It has the highest median rent of the four New Jersey towns, $2,938, and the lowest owner-occupied share, 33.8%, so most people moving here rent. Plan for building rules at both ends of the move: if either building asks for a certificate of insurance, it has to be on file before the truck arrives.
Montclair
Montclair is on NJ Transit’s Montclair-Boonton Line, which runs Midtown Direct trains to Penn Station. Its median gross rent, $2,063, is the lowest of the four New Jersey towns, while its median home value, $906,400, is second only to Summit. About 57% of homes are owner-occupied, so you will find both rentals and houses.
Maplewood
Maplewood is a stop on NJ Transit’s Morris & Essex Lines, which also carry Midtown Direct service into Penn Station. It has the lowest median home value of the New Jersey four, $720,700, which is below New York City’s, and three in four homes (74.9%) are owner-occupied.
Summit
Summit is also on the Morris & Essex Lines and has the shortest average commute of the four New Jersey towns, 33.5 minutes. It also has the group’s highest median home value, $994,500, and a median household income of $190,304.
Looking at other towns? Our list of the best areas to live in New Jersey covers Ridgewood, Westfield, Morristown and more, and our guide to moving from NYC to New Jersey walks through the license, registration and tax changes that come with the move.
Westchester suburbs: Scarsdale, Bronxville, Rye and New Rochelle
Westchester has the widest price gap of any area in this guide. Rye and Scarsdale have median home values above $1.8 million, while New Rochelle’s is $702,500, below New York City’s. All four towns are on Metro-North lines into Grand Central.
Scarsdale
Scarsdale is on Metro-North’s Harlem Line. It has the second-highest median home value in this guide, $1,800,700, and 92.3% of homes are owner-occupied, so this is a market for buyers. Its average commute, 42.5 minutes, is the longest in the table and longer than New York City’s.
Bronxville
Bronxville is also on the Harlem Line, a few stops closer to the city than Scarsdale. It is the smallest town here, with 6,656 residents in the 2020 Census. The median home value is $1,095,100, 84.2% of homes are owner-occupied, and the average commute is 41.3 minutes.
Rye
Rye is on the New Haven Line and has the highest median home value in this guide, $1,819,900. About 70% of homes are owner-occupied, and the average commute is 39.8 minutes.
New Rochelle
New Rochelle is also on the New Haven Line and is the most affordable Westchester option here. It has the lowest median gross rent of the 12 suburbs, $1,917, a median home value of $702,500 and an average commute of 32.5 minutes. With 53.7% of homes owner-occupied, the market is close to an even split between owners and renters.
A move from the city to any of these four towns stays inside New York State, so it falls under state rules rather than federal interstate rules. More on that below.
Long Island suburbs: Garden City and Port Washington
On Long Island, Port Washington has its own LIRR branch, with trains that continue to Grand Central or Penn Station. Garden City is on the Hempstead Branch, where trains run through Jamaica.
Garden City
Garden City has the highest owner-occupied share in this guide, 93.7%, and a median household income of $244,152. The median home value is $1,075,900, the median rent is $3,265 and the average commute is 34.9 minutes.
Port Washington
Port Washington has a median gross rent of $2,184 and a median home value of $1,003,200, with 76.9% of homes owner-occupied and an average commute of 35.4 minutes. Census counts Port Washington as a census-designated place, so its figures describe the community rather than a single village government.
Long Island is part of the area Moishe’s serves, along with Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, New Jersey and Connecticut.
Connecticut suburbs: Greenwich and Stamford
Greenwich and Stamford are both on Metro-North’s New Haven Line, and they post the two shortest average commutes in this guide. Stamford is the lowest-cost option for buyers here; Greenwich is among the most expensive.
Greenwich
Greenwich has a median home value of $1,695,700, a median gross rent of $2,674 and a median household income of $206,130. About 70% of homes are owner-occupied, and the average commute is 29.6 minutes.
Stamford
Stamford is a city of 135,470 people as of the 2020 Census, the largest of the 12 suburbs. It has the lowest median home value of the group, $624,400, a median gross rent of $2,276 and the shortest average commute, 28.5 minutes. At 48.8% owner-occupied, it is the most renter-heavy town in the table after Hoboken.
Connecticut is a different state, so a move here from New York City is an interstate move.
Is it cheaper to live in the suburbs than in NYC?
Not automatically. All 12 suburbs in this guide have a higher median gross rent than New York City, and 9 of the 12 have a higher median home value. What the suburbs offer is a different kind of home for the money, not a lower bill.
Keep in mind that a Census median covers every renter household, including people who have held the same lease for years, so it runs below what a new lease costs today, in the city and in the suburbs alike. To compare fairly, price a real listing in the town you like against what you pay now, then add the monthly rail pass and, if you buy, property taxes, which this table does not show.
If staying in the city is still on the table, see our guide to the most affordable places to live in NYC.
What changes when you move from NYC to the suburbs
Three things change compared with a move inside the city: the rules your mover works under, the size of the home you are loading into, and the timing, because closing dates and lease dates rarely line up.
New Jersey and Connecticut moves are interstate
FMCSA treats a move between a place in one state and a place in another as an interstate move, and the truck does not even have to cross the state line itself for the rules to apply. On these routes your mover must be registered with FMCSA, have a U.S. DOT number and give you the Your Rights and Responsibilities When You Move booklet before the move.
A move to Westchester or Long Island stays in New York State, where household goods movers are licensed by the New York State Department of Transportation. Moishe’s lists its US DOT 587098, NY DOT# 12853 and New Jersey license 39PM000865 in the footer of this site, so you can check them before you book.
From an apartment to a house
At the city end, your building may require a certificate of insurance and a reserved elevator window, and the truck needs legal curb space; our NYC parking rules guide explains your options. At the suburban end, a house usually holds more than the apartment you are leaving, so get your estimate on your full inventory, including anything you plan to buy before the move. Our NYC moving cost guide explains how local and long-distance moves are priced.
When the closing date and your lease don’t match
Buying a house in the suburbs often leaves a gap between the end of your lease and the day you get the keys. Moishe’s owns and operates its own storage facilities, so your belongings can go from the apartment into storage and on to the new house in one plan. Our guide to storage in transit explains how that works.
Book around the calendar, not just the address
Closings, school years and lease ends tend to cluster, so the dates you want may book up early. Our guide to how far in advance to book movers in NYC covers lead times by season, and our change of address checklist keeps the mail, utilities and voter registration on track.
How to choose the right suburb for you
Start with where you work, then narrow by budget and housing type. A short checklist:
- Pick the line before the town. Metro-North runs into Grand Central, PATH reaches 33rd Street and the World Trade Center, NJ Transit Midtown Direct trains run to Penn Station, and Port Washington Branch trains run to Grand Central or Penn Station.
- Decide whether you will rent or buy. Use the owner-occupied column: towns above 85% have few rentals, while Hoboken, Stamford and New Rochelle have plenty.
- Check schools on the state’s own data. New York publishes school results on NYSED data, New Jersey on its School Performance Reports and Connecticut on EdSight.
- Know whether you are crossing a state line. New Jersey and Connecticut mean a new license, registration and tax setup; our New Jersey moving guide covers the deadlines.
- Get a quote built on your inventory. A free moving quote turns the move into a real number you can add to your budget.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best suburb of NYC to live in?
No single town wins on every count. Among the 12 suburbs in this guide, Stamford has the lowest median home value and the shortest average commute, New Rochelle has the lowest median rent, and Garden City and Scarsdale have the highest share of owner-occupied homes. Pick the train line that reaches your office first, then compare the towns on it.
What is the cheapest suburb near NYC?
Among the 12 suburbs compared here, Stamford, Connecticut has the lowest median home value at $624,400, and New Rochelle, New York has the lowest median gross rent at $1,917 a month, based on U.S. Census Bureau estimates for 2020 to 2024.
Is it cheaper to live in the suburbs than in NYC?
Not automatically. All 12 suburbs in this guide have a higher median gross rent than New York City’s $1,821, and 9 of the 12 have a higher median home value than the city’s $777,600. Maplewood, New Rochelle and Stamford are the three with lower median home values.
Is moving from NYC to New Jersey or Connecticut an interstate move?
Yes. FMCSA treats a move between two states as interstate, so your mover must be registered with FMCSA, have a U.S. DOT number and give you the Your Rights and Responsibilities When You Move booklet. A move to Westchester or Long Island stays in New York State, where the New York State Department of Transportation licenses household goods movers.
What if my closing date and my lease end don’t line up?
Put your belongings in storage for the gap. Moishe’s owns and operates its own storage facilities, so your things can go from your apartment into storage and on to the new house once you have the keys.
The bottom line
The right suburb comes down to your train line, whether you rent or buy, and how much home your budget buys in each town. The Census numbers above give you a fair starting point; a visit at rush hour and a real listing will settle the rest.
Moishe’s has been moving New Yorkers since 1983. Get your free moving quote for a number built on your inventory, or see how our local moving and long-distance moving services work.
Get a Free Moving Quote Today